"Five Found Dead"

After setting out to study astrophysics, graduating in law and then abandoning her legal career to write books, Sulari Gentill now grows French black truffles on her farm in the foothills of the Snowy Mountains of Australia.

Gentill’s Rowland Sinclair mysteries have won and/or been shortlisted for the Davitt Award and the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize, and her stand-alone metafiction thriller, After She Wrote Him won the Ned Kelly Award for Best Crime Novel in 2018. Her tenth Sinclair novel, A Testament of Character, was shortlisted for the Ned Kelly Best Crime Novel in 2021.

Gentill applied the Page 69 Test to her new novel, Five Found Dead, and shared the following:

From page 69:

It is actually quite tricky to follow someone on a train without being seen, or so we found. Duplantier’s friend might have been in any of the compartments. We lost him fairly promptly. With no idea where he was, Joe and I decide to return to our own compartment where we can speak unheard. And so it is that we hear something from within 16G as we pass. Joe presses his ear against the door and listens.

“There’s someone in there,” he whispers.

“We should inform— ”

Joe shoves the door to 16G with his shoulder, and I note a fleeting look of surprise on his face when the door flings open.

“Napoleon!” I find myself looking at the Frenchman, who sidesteps hastily to avoid being bowled over by Joe. “What are you—?”

Duplantier places as finger on his lips. A couple of awkward seconds follow wherein we just stare at each other. Finally, the Frenchman speaks.

“This isn’t… I assure you… Allow me to… ” He struggles for some explanation and then, apparently finding nothing even vaguely plausible, shakes his head. He motions me in.

Page 69 is a shorter page, sitting beneath the Chapter 7 header. It features three of Five Found Dead’s most important characters: Meredith Penvale, the narrator, a young woman who gave up her career as a lawyer to support her brother through serious illness; Joe Penvale, Meredith’s twin, a writer who having survived and recovered, is finding his muse on the Orient Express, and the somewhat enigmatic, retired French policeman, Napolean Duplantier. The page finds the three of them in the process of sleuthing. Indeed, it captures the moment when their separate unauthorised investigations run into each other, arguably a microcosm of the overall book in which several “detectives” are running their own inquiries which inevitably collide and cross.

The interaction on this page hints at the natures of Meredith and Joe. She wants to inform someone of the fact that an intruder is in room 16G (the scene of the murder) and he simply barges the door and goes in. As protagonists they embody caution and impulse.

The first line “It is actually quite tricky to follow someone on a train without being seen” is revealing and kind of emblematic of the book as whole. It is tricky to do many things on a train, including write a mystery! The moving train is a closed set in which the spaces are in line, so that in order to reach a particular carriage one must pass through others. Location is crucial and movement complicated. It is not possible to kill someone and simply run away. However, on a train there are many doors through which a murderer may step.

And so page 69 does afford the browser a taste of how Five Found Dead works, but is only a tiny snapshot of the multilayered complications and chaos onboard. It doesn’t really give you an idea of the relationships and connections, some longstanding others newly made, which are at play, and it is neither as thrilling nor as funny as other pages might be. It also does not speak in any way about the influence of story on the way in which we deal with reality—a major theme when one writes a new contemporary mystery on a literary landmark like the Orient Express. Even so, it does give the browser a glimpse, that if limited, is not inaccurate.

Visit Sulari Gentill's website.

Coffee with a Canine: Sulari Gentill & Rowly, Alfie, Miss Higgins and Pig.

--Marshal Zeringue